Thanks for contributing to our forum. I just reviewed the support case you filed on this subject and forwarded the details of the issue over to our technical team for further investigation, but I did ask for some additional clarification to make sure I fully understand the behavior you witnessed prior to when you revised the listings in question.
For example, I posted a test listing through my own Auctiva account using the “Arrange for Local Pick-up (will not ship)” option in the Shipping Tools section, the “Shipping and payments” tab on the listing showed that the only shipping service available was Free Local Pickup.
I'm sorry to hear of your frustration surrounding this manner, but I appreciate you opening a support case to let us know. As I mentioned in my reply, I will follow up with you about the issue as soon as we have been able to find out more.